Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chugger 5368 days ago
I'd choose an iPod Touch or an iPad 1 over a Kindle Fire any day.
2 comments

I have an ipod touch and I ordered a kindle fire because:

1. I want the larger screen. The ipod's is too small for comfortable reading.

2. I want to be able to transfer books to the device without having to go through itunes. Isn't it mysterious that I can copy pictures from the ipod using a usb cable, but cannot copy anything to it?

3. I'm hoping Fire's browser will be able to see shared files on my LAN. Safari on the ipod mysteriously won't, although Safari on the Mac will. This limitation severely limits the usefulness of the ipod, as it cannot see my local shared books, pictures, or music.

I have an older Kindle, which I like very much, but it won't see shared files either. But at least they labeled it's browser as "experimental", so I had no expectations. And I can transfer books to it via usb from my desktop without needing to install anything on the desktop.

Don't get me wrong, I like the ipod a lot. But I want a fire, too [stamps feet].

New/refurbished iPad 1's are available online starting from $200.
Link?

The lowest I've seen is $299 for a refurbished iPad 1 a while back when Apple was trying to clear them out.

The Kindle Fire really has nothing going for it except for the large screen and the price.
Hang on a second. What about Silk? Think about this for a moment: Who wins if web browsing is ridiculously fast?

Amazon is presenting this as a win for users. Perhaps, but not only so. It’s also a win for people who build complicated web applications. Such as... Drum roll... Amazon.com.

What the Kindle claims to have going for it is that I as a consumer can buy a low-end device but enjoy a high-end experience when I use a non-trivial web application such as online shopping.

I'd say it certainly appeals to people who can see the advantages of a small tablet computer but don't want to put down $600 on an iPad 2.
You can get a new/refurbished iPad 1 starting from $200