Are there any easy ways to clean up a PCB that's developed whiskers? And once a whisker erupts on a given PCB, does that generally indicate that others are likely to form on that board in short order?
All else being equal, once growth starts it is likely to start everywhere on that board. This is a probabilistic assumption based on the likelihood of all of the solder on that board being from the same batch and having been applied with the same process parameters. The same cannot be said of the device leads, where each manufacturer and batch could very well be different.
It's quite a nightmare, particularly when you are trying to figure out if this stuff can kill people you want to send into space. The only real mitigation is lead-based solder and coatings on components.
Cleaning? That can be both dangerous and highly ineffective. The whiskers are very strong due to their molecular scale. Mechanical brushing might fracture longer whiskers. Then you have the problem of ensuring that they don't go under devices or in-between contacts. The process would likely have to be repeated many times and include both manual and automated optical inspection as well as x-ray imaging (which might not be able to detect fine whiskers). And then there's the reality that you probably don't want to inhale these things at all.
So, off to the landfill we go. It is likely better to build a new board than to try to clean one. I can't even begin to compute the delta in carbon footprint between making a board with lead-based solder that will last decades and the "clean/green" RoHS board that is sure to end-up in a landfill (cleaning/fixing it is bound to have a massively larger carbon footprint that making a new board).
Unfortunately, all consumer electronics companies have this fetish for making products ever smaller and thinner. It dovetails with their profit motive: make things less reliable so we all have to buy more frequently.
Well actually, there is a way, but you might kill said PCB.
Heat everything up in an oven, the solder will reflow, and you might temporarily fix the board. It’s a similar idea to the Towel/Xbox 360 fix. I can attest to having successfully saved lots of random electronics this way.
All of this started with the eco-friendly alternatives to lead solder, I have a lot of old computer hardware and motherboards, and the hardware from the early 2000s is the least reliable, whereas most game consoles, motherboards, etc. from the 80s and 90s works flawlessly. To this day I swear by the leaded stuff for personal use, it flows better, doesn’t crack, and is superior in every way.
It's quite a nightmare, particularly when you are trying to figure out if this stuff can kill people you want to send into space. The only real mitigation is lead-based solder and coatings on components.
Cleaning? That can be both dangerous and highly ineffective. The whiskers are very strong due to their molecular scale. Mechanical brushing might fracture longer whiskers. Then you have the problem of ensuring that they don't go under devices or in-between contacts. The process would likely have to be repeated many times and include both manual and automated optical inspection as well as x-ray imaging (which might not be able to detect fine whiskers). And then there's the reality that you probably don't want to inhale these things at all.
So, off to the landfill we go. It is likely better to build a new board than to try to clean one. I can't even begin to compute the delta in carbon footprint between making a board with lead-based solder that will last decades and the "clean/green" RoHS board that is sure to end-up in a landfill (cleaning/fixing it is bound to have a massively larger carbon footprint that making a new board).