[andrewgioia]

Related: Lucasfilm hired a digital artist, Shamook, who re-did Luke's scene in The Mandalorian with some improved deepfake techniques[1].

Here's his video comparison: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wrHXA2cSpNU

[1] https://www.engadget.com/lucasfilm-hires-shamook-054904077.h...

[victor9000]

The biggest problem for me is that the mouth movements seem completely off.

[stavros]

I think that's because they used the original fake to make the deepfake. If they had used an actual actor (with a completely different face but accurate mouth movement) I think it would have been spot on.

[SECProto]

It's off on both sides, but to me it looks more off on the deepfake side

[adamsmith143]

That's been an issue for all CGI, I guess our ability to spot even the slightest imperfection in how mouths look has us well stuck in the uncanny valley

[mywacaday]

The firs comment on the video says it would be better if they had access to the original video and not just the original fake.

[jagged-chisel]

His top lip doesn't move when he speaks