Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JumpCrisscross 1568 days ago
> This needs to be criminalized

Literally criminalised? As in you’ll throw people in jail for putting up a pixel? Made illegal, sure.

4 comments

Yes. Make the law clear and lock up CEOs just as you would common stalkers.
Given the, uh, highly variable, quality of government legislation wrt the internet I am seriously skeptical they'd do more good than harm if they tried.

Then again we as an industry and/or community don't seem to be doing too well either.

Not a trivial problem or policy space, sadly.

Wouldn't be a bad idea to be honest

If they're acting so antagonistically against GDPR maybe , for some of the most egregious cases, throwing some people in jail will do the trick

I mean, whoever does the whole song and dance for rejecting cookies that shows a loading gif and takes a while does deserve it

And if you think I'm exaggerating, guess who has the best info now on the Ukraine war? Tiktok.

> If they're acting so antagonistically against GDPR maybe throwing some people in jail will do the trick

This is how you get a legal code like America's, where a cop and prosecutor can put almost anyone in jail with the flimsiest excuse.

I understand the impulse. But the solution to bad enforcement isn't ratcheting up penalties. It's increasing enforcement.

> This is how you get a legal code like America's, where a cop and prosecutor can put almost anyone in jail with the flimsiest excuse.

Then how come America, with its strict procedural safeguards, has that legal environment where people now feel unsafe even talking to cops, whereas many European countries with a more common-sense, less rules-lawyery approach (like the big fines handed out to a lot of privacy-violating tech companies lately) have a much friendlier culture with fewer obvious abuses?

You are correct.

Usually what I find is that the American companies/people usually try to follow the "bare" letter of the law, where Europeans need to follow the spirit, as this is how it is "usually" enforced.

And while the former might let you get away with "one weird trick" the latter usually leaves more margin to interpretation which can be both a blessing and a curse.

Considering this is already illegal, at least under the GDPR and plenty of companies still do so, maybe jail isn't that bad of an idea after all?
No, not jail. Make it a capital offence.