Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by md_ 1576 days ago
As the other commenter said, this has nothing to do with hardware tokens. This has to do with the user agent (the browser) passing the (browser-verified) origin to the authenticator (which can be hardware or software). But, critically, the signatures are also origin-scoped—the message that your user-agent correctly passes to google.com cannot be used by google to sign into microsoft.com.

What’s broken here is not that user agents are or aren’t validating the origin (or relying party)—it’s that the same key+challenge is used for every origin. (As a result, there’s nothing for the user agent to validate, because the same signature is used for all origins!)

It’s like using the same password for every website you log into. As severe understatement, this is a very, very bad protocol design, and nobody should use it.