Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lurquer 1576 days ago
> Napoleon and the Nazis both crossed through that region on their way to Russia

Hitler yes. Napoleon no. The French neither attacked nor retreated through what is now Ukraine.

2 comments

That naive geography positioning reasoning is far from reality. From that point of view Belorussia is more valuable.

That "Mystery of Russian Soul" lies among the lines of "Kiev - mother of Russian cities" (term of 12th century Primary Chronicle) and too many other historical facts. Like Wild Steppe (south of Ukraine) were fought for and liberated from Crimean Khanate by Russian Army. Modern Kherson, Nikolayev, Sevastopol, and Ekaterinoslav(Dnipro/Dnepropetrovsk), were established by Gregory Potemkin (Empress Catherine times) and populated by peasants from Russian heartlands - Tambov, Ryazan, Pskov, etc.

All that is well known and well remembered facts by Russian public. So we should not expect that Russian people will be so against all that. If in doubt then see the above.

These nationalistic narratives are means, not causes. Russia wants to control Ukraine, so they teach these narratives to create public support. It's done in many places about many things. You can see people on HN repeating them about their countries.
Note that I hedged with, "through that region" (because I didn't have time to lookup the route). So which way did they go?
Current Belarus, North of Ukraine.