Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by DerArzt 1581 days ago
As a layperson who doesn't know a whole lot about investing, this sounds like a ponzi scheme.

The way that I am interpreting this is that if I were to invest in one of these (i.e. Maker) then the returns that I would see are there purely because other people are investing in it.

That is close to what most stocks do, but at least with stocks in a company the value is not driven by the mechanism by which it is traded alone, but also by the decisions and profitability that the stocks are backing.
2 comments
aqme28 1581 days ago
> The way that I am interpreting this is that if I were to invest in one of these (i.e. Maker) then the returns that I would see are there purely because other people are investing in it.

That's the opposite of what I'm saying. The returns are from other people using the platform, not from investors in it. For Maker, using the platform means borrowing. For Uniswap, the returns are from a small % fee on trades. It's exactly analogous to a traditional company.

link
lupire 1580 days ago
But what is the platform used for? Converting energy into human comfort, or just another layer of financial engineering?
link
kravens_last 1580 days ago
> But what is the platform used for? Converting energy into human comfort, or just another layer of financial engineering?

This is essentially the "problem" at heart of all crypto "currencies". There is no real world use case that imparts human value, apart from its utility as a speculative vehicle to grow wealth.

Every new DeFi application is a new layer to lock in current adapters who would've otherwise already cashed out. Crypto as a currency is a concept dead in the water because of the perverse incentives of finding every corner of arbitrage between non distinguishable (and frankly worthless) alt tokens/coins.

The entire world of crypto is nothing else but an experiment of how much one could financialize a fully non-regulated, intangible, and imaginary "good" based on nothing but greed.

link
JaimeThompson 1580 days ago
>this sounds like a ponzi scheme.

If it was a ponzi scheme they would be spending millions on advertising and use fear of missing out to get more people to invest.

Wait....

link