Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by goodpoint 1580 days ago
Is it Open Hardware? Where are the schematics?

If not, is it really that different than a thinkpad?

1 comments

I recall a recent HN post about reverse engineering a thinkpad EC in order to get around battery DRM.

With framework that would be doubly unnecessary because the EC firmware is open source. Also they open source stuff having to do with their add on modules.

Plus, I'd wager a guess that Intel/AMD make you sign an NDA that would probably rule an open mainboard (I don't know this for sure). What may need to happen to get high end open hardware is for a company with the right ethos to become big enough to have negotiating power or to design their own SOC.

Framework is trying to strike a balance between producing laptops competitive with mass market offerings and providing users control. If you want freedom over all else you should probably buy a Librem or MNT reform.

> strike a balance

Calling it "balance" is a big stretch when all the important hardware is closed and there are no independent 3rd parties selling replacement parts.