[hinkley]

Almost all of the complexity of VCS is in or around merges. Take away accidental complexity and there is a lot of inherent complexity in merges.

First git project we had a guy who was bad at merges, and his solution was to avoid them as long as he could, which just made things worse. He also disliked another engineer. That engineer was definitely making mistakes but at the end of the day his Dunning Krueger was causing me less trouble than merge boy’s. Also suspect a little ageism, but would not have been able to defend that suspicion.

So one day merge boy was loudly exclaiming that old guy had written a terrible bug and the hit history proved it. Only the bug in question was something I specifically looked for in the code review, and had been happy to find that he had gotten it right. But here in git annotate it shows he got it wrong. What the hell?

So I step through the commit history one commit at a time, sure enough the code was initially correct… until merge boy did a merge and fucked up the three way. Again. And got old guy’s name to show up in annotate. I didn’t even know you could do that.