Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sam0x17 1589 days ago
Political will, yes, but if you think people aren't willing to receive help and all the resources we need are there you are so misguided my friend. We can't even fund student lunches in many states. The primary problem across the board is lack of committing resources. Similarly child allowance tax credit was literally lifting people out of poverty but we don't have the political will to renew it.

People accept help when you give it. This why quite embarrassingly one third of GoFundMe campaigns are to fund medical expenses that wouldn't even have happened with a decent healthcare system. Don't come to me with this argument when literally millions of people are resorting to begging on GoFundMe.

If a child goes home with a coat and comes back without it, they probably have bills and a financial situation at home so dire that they sold the coat.

How is a family of four making $25k/yr supposed to deal with a $120k medical bill when they lack health insurance because this gig economy and the 3 shift jobs they work don't provide it?

1 comments

There is no good reason a kid should go hungry in the US. Federal, state, school, charity food programs make it possible for every kid to eat. But a parent who would steal his kids coat to pay his medical bills (your scenario not mine or likely anyone else's), is the kind of parent who doesn't care enough about their kid to sign up and participate in these programs. You should hang out on r/teachers some time and get a glimpse into what teachers are seeing these days.
It isn't a good argument for why you shouldn't give out resources. Even if parents are going to "steal" the funds, as you say, you are still giving them that much more overhead, and research shows the vast, vast majority of people aren't going to behave like you describe (educate yourself, consume some real leftist content)
Your counter argument would be more persuasive if you provided proof instead of what seems like just another opinion.