|
|
|
|
|
by bluecalm
1586 days ago
|
|
I am familiar with those studies. Still I would like to see the footage of actual elite runners heel striking. I watched quite a lot of it and haven't seen one. My suspicion is that those elite heel strikers are just midfoot strikers in shoes with pronounced heel. As to your studies: the first one doesn't include elite runners so isn't very relevant.
The other one looks like meta analysis of other older studies. I am not arguing that heel strike is definitely wrong btw I am just yet to see an elite runner using it. My intuition is that it's mainly about striking the ground when your foot/leg already moves back. It just doesn't feel natural to do it heel first at least not to me. I am not sure why you think sprinting is about forcefully driving your foot into the ground btw. It's the opposite. It's about lightly "brushing" the ground to "push" it horizontally behind you. See for example this footage:
https://youtu.be/RD_TtokBUKc The heel doesn't even hit the ground. It's the same when you look at the elite 10k or marathon runners although there heel usually lands on the ground for a while, especially in marathon:
https://youtu.be/V4L113lP_54 With those new Nike shoes it almost look like heel strike because of the heel to toe drop in the shoe. |
|
edit - Googled for 30 seconds and found this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=andAaS6Lyc8
The first runner he talks about uses a midfoot strike, the second uses a heel strike. They're both elite marathon runners.
As I said, my conclusion from having looked into this is that this debate is folk science. It might be correct but there's no compelling evidence.