Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Laforet 1601 days ago
Focus or accommodation loss is just the beginning of myopia. Sometime after the symptoms show up, the eye would physically elongate in the axial direction and push the retina beyond the accommodation range of the lens. This change is impossible to "reset" with current medical knowledge.

Your idea about allowing the eye to "rest" is not new and it has been the subject of several large scale clinical trials such as the COMET study linked below. In short, under correcting myopia does help to slow down progression. However, the benefit is too small to justify not fully correcting vision which will result in a better quality of life.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11578789/

1 comments

I see, this study does seem to rule out my view. What's the current consensus about why myopia progressed so quickly in some countries?
The traditional view has always been a combination of genetics and behavior factors, namely reading and other close up work during the age of 8-14 when the eye is still capable of axial elongation. The light intensity theory is a more recent development which has some merits, but more evidence is needed for proof.

After WW2, Canadian Inuits started to send their children to school for the first time in history and myopia became endemic from that generation onwards.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1956268/

And to put the source in context:

- This was before the age of computers and smartphones so screen time was much less of a factor.

- Inuits traditionally spend a disproportionate time indoors due to the climate.

- The schooling was likely shorter and less stressful than those found in places like Japan and Korea, yet the effects are just as apparent.

Similar rises in myopia rate was observed when daily schooling was introduced to many other places, but few occur on the same scale. Thus it is possible that Asians and Inuits are genetically predisposed to myopia and it took until the modern age for this to become a problem.