Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by edtechdev 1611 days ago
This Falstad animated circuit simulation has been the best at conceptually understanding what's going on in circuits: https://falstad.com/circuit

Click on the 'Circuits' menu to see dozens of example circuits.

One issue with the hydraulic/fluid analogy is the "empty pipe" misconception - we forget or don't know that in electrical circuits, the circuit is a closed loop. An example of this misconception is that beginners sometimes think the current "wears out" as it goes along the wire. The Falstad simulation shows a line of moving dots that move faster or slower depending on the current - a little more like a train moving in a pipe - which helps counter this misconception, although it, too, isn't perfect. As a next level, I like showing animations/simulations that show the role of charge on the 'outside' of the wire in steering current flow, as well as magnetic fields surrounding the wire.

4 comments

Those are exceptional. I remember gaining really nice math and physics intuition from his "applets" years ago. Yes, those started as Java applets if anyone still remembers those.

Here are math and physics ones: https://falstad.com/mathphysics.html

I like the 2D vector field one https://falstad.com/vector (2d) and the 3d one https://falstad.com/vector3d.

Antenna simulator: https://falstad.com/antenna

Waveguide is awesome too https://falstad.com/embox/guide.html. Don't forget to pick various modes in the little square at the bottom.

If Paul Falstad comes around these parts, thank you for creating and sharing those!

I'm pretty sure this is the one that I found while in undergrad physics. That diagram helped me gain a level of visual understanding that I hadn't obtained from hobby DC circuit tinkering. I remember feeling very grateful to exist during a time when an interactive web app could show me what would have taken N hours in an electronics lab to see in years prior. Many thanks Paul Falstad.
A "closed" circuit is just an open circuit plus a pump (electron pump or water pump).

Open circuits work fine if there is a powerful source of electricity (like a a radio) and a sink (like the Earth), and same for water (an icy comet crashing into a cliff, making a waterfall).

An open water circuit is full of stationary water.

Falstad is a really excellent education tool. I used it myself as an undergrad and as a tutor. Can't recommend it enough.