Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ComSubVie 1615 days ago
Why not ban ALL ads?!?
3 comments

Once in a rare while there's an ad which makes me want to buy something but I don't know if it's worth all the noise.

Something really sad is that sometimes you search for something you actually want to buy like, say, winter tire chains for your car... Then you end up buying them but for two weeks you keep getting ads: because the system has no way of knowing you actually now bought some at the petrol station down the street.

I run pi-hole now: works great and seems to at least take care of the worst offenders.

If you want to be informed of product suggestions you could sign up for a service like that.

I think we should ban all ads, but I would use such a service if it worked well.

Bold stance! I think it goes too far - there is definitely value for society in people being able to make services and goods they offer publicly known. No doubt we're currently too far in the "ads everywhere" direction, but within limits I think ads can have net benefit.
If that's the only reason for accepting ads, then they could be consigned to particular websites and stop polluting the world for the rest of us. Then, if you need something, you can go watch all the stupid ads.
are you willing to send money over paypal to each website you ever visit?
Depends on the content. For some: yes, for sure.

For some others I should get money back because I couldn't find what was advertised before (for example recipe sites that contain mostly Blabla with interspersed ads and only a rudimentary recipe that isn't reproducible).