Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by version_five 1609 days ago
Yeah who knows what unequivocal advice we could be getting from experts right now that will be thoroughly debunked 70 years from now.

(Are dairy and grains still food groups... I could easily go on)

6 comments

>(Are dairy and grains still food groups... I could easily go on)

I don't get it. Are you saying that grain shouldn't be a food group? I think for the purposes of categorizing foods, "starchy staples" is a pretty useful categorization, even if the recommendation to eat 8 servings a day or whatever is misguided.

He's probably referring to the food pyramid, in which those food groups were put forth as foundational building blocks of a healthy diet according to the USDA. [1] That saga overlapped with the sugar lobby blaming fats for heart issues [2], and using their weight with the FDA to keep % Daily Values for sugars off food labels until very recently. [3]

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8375951/

[2] https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074...

[3] https://www.vox.com/2016/5/20/11719796/new-nutrition-label-a...

High Fructose Syrup is the one I'm holding out hope on.

Social Media consumption is another.

Yet the current zeitgeist is "Trust the experts, fool!"

We never frikkin learn.

Using the word "science" to frame your argument automatically discredits any counterpoint.
This is why there is supposed to be separation of church and stage, but such rules didn't anticipate "science" becoming religion that is exempt from the criticism of religion. We need some updated principles that separate dogma and faith from legitimate motivations
some humans have been drinking animal dairy for so many thousands of years that some ethnicities have evolved to have a lactose breaking down mutation into adulthood
>evolved

Not disagreeing, but that's a much nicer way of saying that nobody wanted to mate with the ones having constant diarrhea.

The amount of dairy and refined dairy products people consume today, like meat, is orders of magnitude bigger than back in the day.
Vegetable/seed oils is one I’ve been seeing recently.
That vaping and nicotine is harmless (just like coffee!) despite seeing the negative effects of nicotine intake on developing fetuses.