Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mrow84 1614 days ago
It reduces the probability of disease. It isn’t binary.
1 comments

Apologies for pedantry...

Vaccines reduce the severity of disease, sometimes to the point of no noticeable effect. They may reduce probability of transmission.

Can't both be true? You don't seem to be disagreeing with parent poster?
Some vaccinated people still get severe disease, and others even die (both at significantly lower rates than for the unvaccinated, of course). The reasons why this happens in some cases and not others is uncertain, and, accepting the Bayesian interpretation of probability as I do, I would describe that as reducing the probability of disease (and also death). Put differently, you cannot tell a priori whether being vaccinated will definitely stop you dying, but you can observe that the a posteriori population level rate is reduced. You are correct that it also reduces the probability of transmission.