[rastapasta42]

Big difference is that Uyghurs are not rapists and murderers, and they didn't commit crimes.

What's wrong with prison labor in US? Those criminals committed acts deemed bad for society.

We could either pay for them to stay in a fancy hotel, or make them pay back debt to society.

This is not comparable to imprisoning people based on ethnicity.

[mrweasel]

Aren’t people in prison to get rehabilitated? They don’t really repay anything to society by working for pennies for a prison run by a private company.

In fact you could argue that prisoners are stealing job from others by working for next to nothing.

[999900000999]

You also create strange perverse incentives to keep as many people in prison as possible.

And those people in prison working for pennies per day ,as you've alluded, take jobs from free people. If you want to see peak absurdity, California has legions of prisoner firefighters.

But you can be a firefighter with a felony on your record, so while the state of California is fine with paying them peanuts for risking their lives, it won't make them full-fledged firefighters once they're released.

If any other country was doing this, our various propaganda agencies would be crying foul.

[sdk16420]

What is a crime depends on local legislation. Being homosexual is a crime in many countries, hence there is still nothing wrong with 'criminals' performing forced labour?