Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by short12 1626 days ago
Rabies is crazy. Basically if you get it you die. There are a few exceptions like the girl in Wisconsin a while back

And she wasnt doing something stupid either. If I recall correctly she grabbed a rafter in her Attic and bam

4 comments

> Basically if you get it you die.

There's a critical (literally life and death) clarification to be made here. As far as I know, it's emphatically not true that you're doomed as soon as you are infected with rabies. My understanding is that a rabies infection is actually quite treatable if caught early. That's why, if you think there is any chance that you've bit bitten by a rabid animal, you should seek treatment immediately.

I think its when you begin exhibiting symptoms that you're basically a goner. If that's what you mean by "get it," then I don't disagree with your comment. But I'm not sure that's how people would interpret it.

Yes. Your statement is correct. It's "basically harmless" once it enters your body until it bumps into nerve cells. At which point you're almost certainly going to die unpleasantly.

My grandfather worked with rabies and I interviewed him for a school project. I remember being rather uncomfortable with his description of the disease. Perhaps a bit much to chew for a 4th grader. Anyway, the "once you show symptoms, you're dead" part really stuck with me.

I thought the survival rate was extremely high if you get the vaccine very soon after being bitten?
If you get the vaccine before showing symptoms, it's pretty much 100% survival.

If you show symptoms and haven't got the vaccine it's pretty much 100% fatal.

Wild.

No there's a high chance of survival if you get the vaccine and/or glycoprotein before showing symptoms.

A handful of people have survived entirely without.

> Basically if you get it you die.

Jeanna Giese (and six others) would disagree with you; and everyone else who where saved by the vaccine.

About 50k die each year while the total number of people that survived after onset of symptoms can be counted on two hands. "Basically if you get it you die" is a quite good description. The vaccine is more a way to ensure you don't get it (the illness, not the virus), and it's useless once the illness actually sets in.
My statement wasn't an absolute, hance the basically allows for room for exceptions. Which 6-7 people really do count as a super tiny minority. So what was your point again?