Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kennylevinsen 1631 days ago
> That would depend on if you knew more about how the code is intended to work than the original author of the code. Do you presume to know more about how this code is intended to work than the original author?

I am not sure if you are suggesting that only the author can know how code is supposed to work, that finding bugs require understanding of the code strictly superior to the author, or that the author is infallible and intended every behavior of the current operation.

Either way, this attitude would not have made for a healthy open source contribution environment.

1 comments

> that finding bugs require understanding of the code strictly superior to the author,

Evaluating whether or not something is a bug in a specific part of a system absolutely requires understanding the intent of the code equal to the author. You have found undesirable application-level behavior and have attributed the cause to a specific line of code in the kernel but it’s possible you are missing the bigger picture of how everything is intended to work. Just because latency has been tracked down to that line of code does not mean the root source of that latency is that line of code. Symptoms vs root causes.