Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by inglor_cz 1637 days ago
"efficiently"

This is the weasel word.

In war, especially a war of national survival, one can argue that winning the war is the important cause and all others are of secondary importance. So you can actually use the word "efficient" about distribution of goods without first discussing the ends of said distribution. The main end is simply to win, or at least not to lose catastrophically.

In peacetime, there isn't a single primary objective, but a multitude of smaller, competing ones. Once you start speaking of "efficient distribution of goods", you imply existence of a ladder of importance on which these objectives are sorted.

An example: is it more efficient if Peter and Paul have one car each or if Peter has two cars and Paul has none? Well, it depends what they do with them, no? What if Paul is legally blind and cannot drive? (But radicals might still argue that Peter having two cars is a big no-no because it increases inequality.)

1 comments

Sue me, I have whatever concept of efficiency that means that people eating and having housing and having a habitable environment is more important than NFT's or space tourism or car collections. That's my ladder of importance. So weasely!
That ladder of importance isn't as simple as you present it.

Having housing of which quality? What floor size per person? In what location? You can buy an entire empty house in depopulated Italian villages for 1 euro, which isn't a prohibitive cost for anyone, but there seem to be few takers [1].

Is space tourism necessary for promotion of space research in general? What about the money it brings into various coffers? Maybe it contributes to having habitable environment in the future.

As for eating, Coca-Cola and McDonalds are ready to drown the entire world in cheap sugary fast food. That probably isn't what you had in mind - this kind of eating will kill people slowly. Is it possible to feed 8 billion people just with organic food? Probably not either. Etc.

[1] https://www.idealista.it/en/news/tags/1-euro-homes-italy/