Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by foobarbecue 1641 days ago
If you haven't seen Gattaca, you should
2 comments

There should be a directors cut where the mission fails because of Vincent's hidden heart condition.

Gattaca shows eugenics has been so vilified that the audience will root for a character who selfishly commits fraud, risking lives and scientific progress for his own vanity.

The really scary fact is that there would be no need for a police state and segregation. The genetically enhanced would just completely dominate an open and fair competition.

Gattaca shows a society in which eugenics, in hopes of creating a shortcut for people who have supposedly the better genes, devolved into a society where someone who did not have genetic augmentation could outcompete a whole bunch of genetically augmented people.

In the movie, either the genetic augmentation didn't work (as well) as expected, or their advantage caused the augmented people to become lazy because they got covered in undeserved status no matter how little or much they worked, as everything depended on which genes they have been "bred" for. Then someone with supposedly bad genes could run circles around them just by working hard.

Maybe some mixture, e.g. in order to protect those kids who fail at the task they have been "bred" for from considering themselves failed humans, gattaca's society adopted this model where they shower all kids in status who have the right genes. Maybe it's not the kids who are being protected but the companies selling the augmentations.

100% Agree. Gattaca actually showed A SPACE PROGRAM running similar to the real space programs. I don't know about now but the first astronauts needed certain genes or they weren't allowed in. AFAIK that used to be true for fighter pilots. Want to be one you needed perfect eye sight. Bad genes = selected out.
Yeah super good!!