Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by xbryanx 1639 days ago
This sounds like every interaction I've had asking a question in a plumbing/electrician forum. Oh, if you're asking that question your definitely going to poison your entire house with sewer gas and/or burn the place down with that wiring.
2 comments

It's _exactly_ like that - and I've asked a fair few questions on DIY forums and the answer is, invariably, "you should hire someone to do that".

It's even worse in the UK if you mention gas. If you so much as mention a boiler you'll be pounced on by the cartel inventing their own legislation.

If you knew me you would understand why these warnings are necessary...
Warnings are most certainly necessary, but they should be accompanied by the actual answer, else GTFO.

It seems like these fields are filled with people who can't stand DIY and just try and get everyone to pay for professional services.

When I try and replace a burnt fuse and ask for help, I accept that I'm not a professional and might burn my house down. Just tell me the risks and how to do it. I'm not a child, and I'm not going to sue someone when I've said upfront that nobody becomes liable just because they gave me advice.

Reminds me of David Mitchell's bit/rant in Would I Lie To You: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mKc32jQIY0w (01:28 if you're in a hurry).
That was lovely, thank you. He is an international treasure.