Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ekianjo 1648 days ago
China's economy would crumble a little if it could not sell anything outside anymore. Imagine a few billions of people losing their current level of life in China... a good recipe for regime change.
3 comments

All that would happen is that the Chinese government would become even more authoritarian and a whole lot of people would be worse off. These fantasies always seem to ignore the human cost.
> All that would happen is that the Chinese government would become even more authoritarian and a whole lot of people would be worse off. These fantasies always seem to ignore the human cost.

Your suggestion is that the rest of the world should play nice with China, and accept an invasion of a free nation (Taiwan) and its people because not doing so would hurt Chinese nationals within China?

Chinese people suffering due to the CCP is bad, certainly. But what's worse is another country (having nothing to do with the CCP) suffering for it.

Now imagine all those Chinese factories being repurposed for the sole purpose of producing armaments as happened in the West during WW2.
Europe is much smaller than you think.
US has 40% of world GDP and EU ~32%. If you include non-EU countries they're neck and neck.
Not quite as small. Combined EU has the largest economy in the world, is by far the wealthiest region on the planet, possesses a huge & advanced military force and despite decline still has pretty substantial manufacturing capacity. (only reason US tops these rankings is because in EU each metric is tracked separately for each country).

So if EU got its shit together and formulated a coherent unified foreign policy - it would be at the very least on equal terms with both US and China. Hence why everyone (from Putin, to China to even our allies the US) are so invested in breaking EU apart (and even succeeding - the Brexit).

> Combined EU has the largest economy in the world

Second largest, at $17.1tn, after the US ($22.7tn), but ahead of China ($16.6tn).[1]

> is by far the wealthiest region on the planet

North America is the wealthiest region, with the United States alone having a total wealth of $126tn. European wealth is around $103tn.[2]

1. World Economic Outlook Database, April 2021

2. https://www.credit-suisse.com/media/assets/corporate/docs/ab...

> Combined EU has the largest economy in the world

Unfortunately (?) not. By nominal GDP the US is the largest. By PPP-adjusted GDP China comes first.

> So if EU got its shit together and formulated a coherent unified foreign policy - it would be at the very least on equal terms with both US and China.

On approximately equal terms, yes, probably.