Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cycomanic 1651 days ago
In fact health care is an example where the majority favors a government (or primarily government) paid solution [1], but it does seem unlikely to ever be implemented.

Climate change is another issue which actually has majority support in the US, but action is very little [2,3].

In fact I believe the perception of it being contentious issues is largely due to a relatively small minority which has a disproportionate influence on policy (and likely corporate lobbying will have influence as well). This is actually on e of the issues that alternative voting schemes want to address, diminishing the influence of a minority which has very strong/extreme views.

[1] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/09/29/increasing-... [2] https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2020/06/23/two-thirds-of... [3] https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2019/11/25/u-s-public-vi...

1 comments

When I look at these health care charts, I don't see a real consensus, even when oversimplifying health care to 4 broad categories (36 20 30 6 percent respectively). I don't know who the respective corporate interests would be for each of the categories, though I'd guess that there's big corporations that favor 2 or 3 of these potential solutions, and only a third (at most) of Americans that support one of them. A third of the populace doesn't make a popular mandate, and it certainly isn't enough for a senate majority (especially for democrats).

The climate change one might be more convincing, but I actually think we've seen some real progress on this. Alternative energy is getting cheaper, there's tax incentives for installing solar panels or EV chargers in many areas, and tax incentives for buying EVs. There's certainly more we can do, and the polls were phrased to suggest that the general public thinks so too. But if the admittedly significant oil and gas lobby is trying to hold this issue back, I'm not sure how successful they've been. Finally, this isn't an actual bill or anything. Every "green" bill I've seen is opposed by conservatives based on their constituency, whether they're a red conservative from texas, or a blue conservative from west virginia. I don't know if Joe Manchin takes donations from coal companies, but he'd unquestionably support coal either way.