| The term "general inheritance" was not familiar to me as "inheritance across package structures". However, my OOP design intuition feels pretty good about that idea. This quickly devolves into the inheritance vs. composition argument which isn't where I thought the Author wanted to go (but then sort of ended up going there). I agree with other commenters that it's an overstated idea. Inheritance is ridiculously useful in the right design structure, as is Composition. They both have a place. (Incidentally, bad Inheritance design usually looks very ugly very fast - bad Composition is often less glaring). I find that years of designing in OOP has led me to build designs that have a goal of preventing me from making future mistakes and correctly consider implications of my code. I find that my most immediate designs tend me towards Abstract Classes and Interfaces. While I usually get credit for "programming to the Interface" for this, that's not what usually led me there. I like abstract methods. They (i.e. the compiler will) FORCE me to think about something if I ever decide to create another subclass of the Abstract class. The Author points out the "forget to call super" bug which is particularly nefarious and I avoid it at all costs. I can do that by providing a final concrete method which calls the abstract method. Let the subclasses implement that and never worry about super. Anyway - governing inheritance across package hierarchies seems like a reasonable guideline. As for Inheritance vs. Composition, I don't favor either. When designing a class structure, I just make my best guess (as we'd all do) and find the structure quickly evolves on it's own. Usually, this ends up in a blend of shallow Inheritance trees with logical composition. There's always multiple Class Structures that will work - my goal is to find a reasonable one of those. |
I’ve made very little use of inheritance since I turned my back on C++/Java a decade and change ago. Can you give some examples where you feel inheritance wins out over composition?