Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by RSZC 1656 days ago
Huh, I didn't expect to come across something I have such direct knowledge of.

I used to work with this data directly - I worked with MACPAC to prepare reports for the CBO on the efficacy of pay-per-performance programs, especially as it pertained to the possibility of switching Medicaid from a fee-for-service model to a pay-for-performance model. (6-9 years ago)

I just wanted to chime in on this one quote:

> We have all the data we need to know what the outcomes should be for a provider over the course of a year.

The data here is exceedingly low quality, especially for Medicaid. Medicare is in a better state due to being centrally administered. We do *not* have all the data we need to make pay-for-performance more than an extremely rudimentary approach. Is that rudimentary approach still better than fee-for-service? Maybe - that's a complicated question I let the public health PHDs write very long reports on.