Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by zepto 1679 days ago
Right, but there was never an asterisk. There was slavery, and a set of ideals which were ultimately incompatible with it, and a bunch of people who wanted to keep profiting from it.

No asterisks. Just a disagreement which was settled by a war.
1 comments
sangnoir 1678 days ago
> Just a disagreement which was settled by a war.

This brushes over a lot history - there barely was an abolitionist movement when the constitution was written, and you missed the 3/5 compromise (and compromise means there's agreement). "We the people*" was definitely asterisked with "Slaves excluded", and updated a little later - with consent of northern states - to "slaves are 3/5ths people"

link
zepto 1676 days ago
It wasn’t asterisked with anything. Slaves were excluded.

Compromise doesn’t mean people ‘agree’ on some truth. You can twist language to make the claim that everyone agreed with slavery, but that is clearly a dishonest claim.

link