Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jgwil2 1677 days ago
> But for longer works where the proof is decomposed into multiple lemmas and sub-lemmas, these can be very useful.

Wouldn't they be better off as an actual table of contents though, rather than in paragraph form?

2 comments

At least in CS venues, page limits disincentivize formatting that takes up more space—even when it's more readable.
another reason why we should get rid of page limits
I don't want to review for a conference with no page limits.
No, because it's hard to accurately represent the tree structure and interdependence of lemmas with a linear table of contents. (Sometimes – not always!)

But for really nasty proofs, I think a graphic description of the structure is best. Check out Figure 3 on page 29 of this paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/1108.2291.