Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by coliveira 1678 days ago
That's not paranoid at all. MS goal is to declare Linux a "legacy" environment, like they tried to do with UNIX in the 80s (the so called POSIX subsystem).
3 comments

The part that really pains on this, is it is a common pattern in our entire industry. :(
Secure boot could be a good feature, but it can be severely abused. Some people really put effort in it to make it more secure. But the usual problems of certificate logistics leads to the case the Microsoft basically owns secure boot.

Only a matter of time before Netflix demands remote attestation.

>Only a matter of time before Netflix demands remote attestation.

Which is completely absurd. Within minutes of Netflix/anyone releasing anything new I can download it via Usenet or torrents. Nothing anyone does will change that reality. They just continue to make it more difficult for the average user to access content via player requirements for various DRM schemes. Which funny enough pushes people back to pirating to avoid all the nonsense.

It must be soul crushing to work on DRM for any industry as your job. Knowing that no matter what you do, how clever you are, etc - it doesn't matter at all, it'll be bypassed very shortly.

> It must be soul crushing to work on DRM for any industry as your job. Knowing that no matter what you do, how clever you are, etc - it doesn't matter at all, it'll be bypassed very shortly.

I can't imagine doing this, to be honest if I were asked to implement DRM I would quit, or try to make sure there are fundamental flaws in the scheme, it's the only moral thing to do if you're put in that situation imo.

EDIT: To those upvoting me, software as a service is usually DRM, so maybe hold your upvote if you're complicit.

> Only a matter of time before Netflix demands remote attestation.

They already do on Android. Root your device and either play cat and mouse with Magisk and Universal SafetyNet fix, or get downgraded to L3. And even then, it's uncertain how long the USN hack will last, given that all it does is pretend the device doesn't have hardware attestation - once Google decides to mandate HA for all Android 12 and above devices (as all SoCs capable of running that should have some form of secure element), it's game over.

We need legislative action against anti-rooting measures and other shit that takes away control of devices from users, and that fast, but it doesn't look like it's high on the priority list for the next year of the Biden admin, and after that we will likely see, once again, a gridlocked Congress and in 2024 the Rise of the Sith again.

> Only a matter of time before Netflix demands remote attestation.

Well, as soon as they do that they become useless for me and I'll unsubscribe.

I don't know how many people are on the same boat, but between badly developed smart tvs and top boxes there are probably a large number.

Bye, Netflix.
I think of Windows as a legacy environment, having abandoned it when Windows 7 ended. That's when Microsoft exited the operating system business and entered the ad business.
> MS goal is to declare Linux a "legacy" environment

Your information is a decade out of date. More than half of Azure instances run Linux, and it's a huge source of income for MS now. Billions huge.