Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rocqua 1680 days ago
There is a difference between "Questions" and "test questions with a known specific solution". One could argue (I would not) that the solution to a test question is an integral part of the question and therefor if the one can be protected by copyright, so can the other".
4 comments

While that would apply to simple maths questions — 16x16 is always 256 — I don’t see that applying to HackerRank programming challenges, where the challenges (last time I used it) are essentially “produce correct output from this mostly-secret input”, and they don’t even mind which language you use to do this, never mind what variable names you use.
Is there any legal basis for that argument?
Nope
At least in this case, there can be multiple correct answers using different approaches, in that case your theory leads to further confusion.
It such a question exists, surely it is the exception that proves the rule.