[dmitriid]

> The thing I like most about react is that it’s just executing plain Javascript most of the time.

Then explain what hooks do ;)

Hooks are decidedly not Javascript (even if they look like Javascript), and are a much more weird construct than {#await promise}

[_hzrk]

No, they are JavaScript, it is array based programming wrapped in a reactive functional-declarative approach. Simply array of objects cascading with state. {#await promise} is more cryptic than any useHook function implementation.

[dmitriid]

> No, they are JavaScript, it is array based programming wrapped

Javascript has no support for array-based programming.

So, hooks are not Javascript: they look like regular function calls, but:

- they can only be declared and called before rendering

- they can't be called out of order

- they cannot be called conditionally

- they have to be called a specific name to be handled correctly by React runtime

- some (but not all of them) require dependency lists that determine how they are invoked

> {#await promise} is more cryptic than any useHook function implementation.

usEffect documentation is something like 20 pages long. The use of {#await promise} is immediately understandable from the code example, and its entire documentation fits on a page and a half

[Aeolun]

They are definitely javascript. I can click to definition of the useEffect function and see exactly what it is doing.

I completely agree that learning them is a bit crazy, but ultimately every hook comes down to being a function execution.

[dmitriid]

> They are definitely javascript.

How come they break Javascript semantics and execution flow?

> but ultimately every hook comes down to being a function execution.

That's really beside the point when it comes to understand what something is and using them.

{#await promise} is immediately understandable from its use.

Hooks are... well, I already said above.

[merb]

> How come they break Javascript semantics and execution flow?

wait what? since when do they break execution flow and javascript semantics?!

useEffect(function () { }); when exactly do you think the function will be called? - correct only the "framework" defines that, but that's completly normal javascript execution and semantic.