[pboutros]

_What if they want to sleep on the street?_ Let's start by sheltering as many people as we can, and when our problem becomes "too many empty beds", then we can move on to that problem.

_Where do we build them?_ I bet there are choices we can make that house 100+ people for every 1 person who is mildly inconvenienced.

_Are there barriers to living in these dorms?_ No.

[mulmen]

Homelessness is not a single problem. We can't pretend there is a single solution. Reality is more complex than just saying "build beds" and not adding any rules or guidelines.

Why should recovering addicts be forced to live in a setting where they are tempted by drugs? Why shouldn't they be given a chance to live in a drug-free setting?

Why should victims of abuse be forced to live near potential abusers? Shouldn't we consider their needs?

Clearly we need shelters suited to the needs of individuals.

But what are those needs, and what do we do if someone refuses the opportunity? I don't think "ignore them" is a satisfactory answer.

[pboutros]

Nobody in these threads is saying that housing them is the silver bullet. But shelter is part of the foundation of a human's hierarchy of needs, and being anything but single-minded about people's right to shelter distracts from helping them obtain it.

[mulmen]

That’s an absurd statement. As you say, there is no silver bullet. In other words there is no single-threaded solution. We have to do better.