[godaddy]

loganlinn,

I can't know the exact details of this situation, but in a normal PayPal reversal scenario, you can call Support, pay for the reversal with a different payment method (as you suggested would be done), and the service would be returned to your account. If this hasn't been resolved with our Online Support Team yet, I encourage you to make that call - 480.505.8877 - and I have every reason to believe it would be resolved quickly.