[md8z]

I don't understand your analogy. If a smelter is using something in a bad or inefficient way and a smith is capable of explaining it to them, then that would be beneficial to do so. People do not have to do exactly the same job in the exact same way in order to discuss how a specific tool works.

Like you, I went through a period where I tried pretty much every tiling window manager I could find. And I can say with confidence: they are all broken and awful, in part because the very concept of tiling doesn't really work. The design is flawed. It's like you are making a comparison between every jigsaw on the shelf and picking out the best one but are missing that you could get a miter saw and that would work even better for your use case. Does that explain it?