Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by LeoPanthera 1693 days ago
Keeping DST year round just seems so crazy. If "midday" and "midnight" no longer approximate the middle of the day and night then what is even the point of time zones?

The reason we don't all use UTC is because it is useful to be able to figure out roughly what time of day it is somewhere else on the planet. If we collectively agree that is no longer necessary then we are giving up a fundamental part of timekeeping.

If you want an example of how crazy this is, just look to China, which only has a single time zone. It is so large that in some parts of the country the sun doesn't set until "midnight".

Time actually means something, don't mess with it.

3 comments

Madrid's solar noon is around 1 PM during standard time and 2 PM during summer time, the rest of Spain is a bit off from this, and I noted when I lived there that the Spanish custom seems to be to keep later hours.
Spain should be on GMT. It was a political decision by Franco to align timezones with Germany during WWII.
Interestingly the UK also changed to GMT+1 during the war.

And during the Spanish Civil war Republicans had already moved to GMT+1 in 1938, a change that was undone after the war before switching again to GMT+1 in 1940.

If "midday" didn't get changing twice a year and always coincided with noon (i.e. the sun being highest), we could build a schedule based on working when there is light on the sky and still have some left after work.

> Time actually means something, don't mess with it.

That would be great advice for not changing the clock every six months.

To be clear, I am fully on board with abolishing daylight saving. We should standardize on the aptly named standard time.
There is a huge difference between keeping the same time all year versus keeping the same time over huge swaths of the globe. We only keep "regular" time just over four months a year now.