Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by staticman2 1695 days ago
Talk therapy where I am pays 75 dollars for 50 minute session on my insurance.

Someone who has been through med school would not typically lower themself to that rate, nor do I buy the idea that some insurers are inexplicably more generous and pay doctor rates for non doctor work.

Remember, talk therapy does not require as much education, you do not need a phd or md to do it. An MD would not get doctor level payouts doing talk therapy.

1 comments

It's true an LISW or similar wouldn't make the same rated as a PhD or an MD... but between the same "tier" of education in the provider, rates are surprisingly more comparable.

Insurers aren't more generous - they have negotiated rates. They're never paying 100% of what's charged. Some providers are better at negotiating, or have more leverage, than others.

You don't have to believe me when I say psychiatrists don't tend to do things not involving drugs, you can read this quora thread:

https://www.quora.com/Why-don-t-psychiatrists-do-talk-therap...

You've shared a belief that a patient will continue to see a psychiatrist when not being given drugs. Since psychiatrists don't tend to do talk therapy, I will reiterate I don't believe this is correct.

I'm sure there are exceptions- a wealthy person might find a Doctor Frasier Crane type Doctor to do talk therapy- but they would be paying out of pocket. I know the local Ivy League school only takes a special Ivy League insurance offered only to the Ivy league school's students and staff. The wealthy- and their Doctors- don't need to worry about the "rules" set by insurance companies.