Y
Hacker News
new
|
ask
|
show
|
jobs
by
AlexCoventry
1700 days ago
Would that be cryptographically secure? Couldn't someone perturb an RNG based on background radiation by beaming radiation at it?
2 comments
ars
1700 days ago
That shouldn't change anything:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_coin#Fair_results_from_a_...
link
AlexCoventry
1700 days ago
That argument relies on independent samples, but if someone's beaming radiation at the device to control its output, the samples will not be independent.
link
ars
1700 days ago
It's not that easy to control radiation, controlling it to the level of individual decays is not possible.
The closest you can get is bring it closer/further, or shield/unshield.
link
AlexCoventry
1700 days ago
I'd rather use a local source in a Faraday cage, so that it's not possible for someone to influence the output at all.
link
ars
1699 days ago
A Faraday cage is not going to block this type of radiation.
link
gabrielblack
1699 days ago
To test, I made a simple script generating the dispersion graph: the numbers seem to be of good quality
link