|
|
|
|
|
|
by dpnmn
1710 days ago
|
|
|
I trust you if you say that your project and code base is great, without DI (of that particular kind). But the comment was about your examples, and they are not great - they appear to be created to show how useless or overcomplicated DI is. And it is overcomplicated - in your toy examples. However, there are plenty of better examples on the net of the benefits of DI, but in order to actually show any usefulness they either have to be large, or depend on the readers to "extrapolate" to larger/more complicated code bases. |
|
|
The first draft dragged on as I tried to give a concrete example (API + Service + DB CRUD) in various implementations (Erlang gen_servers, CL CLOS, JS currying, C# with/out automated DI etc). I have a hard time tying my lose ends when writing, so I opted by a simpler example, perhaps swinging the bell too far the other way.
Thank you (all) for pointing it out, I missed it completely :)
My comment above was to exemplify that there perhaps is a span between everyone-is-wrong (by some definition of everyone) and the-author-is-inexperienced.