Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by INTPenis 1713 days ago
All valid points but there is another perspective to this whole mess.

I see it through my family members who all have Facebook, how they connect with relatives across the globe and routinely stay in touch during birthdays and other events.

I also see it at most social functions around me that organize over Facebook, because I am left out of those since I don't have an account.

My best connection to social gatherings is a friend who also hates Facebook but is a lot more social than me, moves around a lot more, so he hears from all the people with Facebook what is going on through word of mouth.

So that's a pretty neat service they're offering to a substantial part of the population. But of course they're suffering from moderation issues, something we can see on all large platforms like Youtube and Twitter.

1 comments

> So that's a pretty neat service they're offering to a substantial part of the population.

For sure, Facebook is great. It just provides services that shouldn't come from one single company in America.

They should be forced to interoperate. Provide a way to subscribe to Facebook content (pages, events) from outside of Facebook, and a way to pull outside content (RSS, ActivityPub, hell, throw in Twitter while we're at it) into your Facebook stream. A sort of standardized stream for updates and comments.

This would clear up all my criticisms of Facebook. At that point I would only wish them well. I'm sure they would provide the best interface to it, and most people would stay with them, and that would be fine.

The thing that's insane to me is you can't even access any profiles without being logged in. This is public information; they've locked things down to an incredible degree and I bet every last dollar I have it's for cynical reasons and not "user privacy"
Of course I agree because I'm from a traditionally socialist country. But you reap what you sow in a free market economy.

I just don't see the US implementing such measures. But I do hope for a municipal social media platform in Europe some day.