Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by darthvoldemort 1710 days ago
This is completely BS. The activists have been trying for decades to bump up the percentage of Blacks and Latinos, and yet it's dominated by Asians. Asians are "stealing" spots from White, Blacks, and Latinos and it makes it hard to justify racism, especially when Asians are not only 40% of the G&T but also the poorest demographic in NYC.
2 comments

You called this BS, but you haven't refuted anything in it...

Can you be a little more precise, please?

If poverty is not a distinguishing factor, then what is left but racism? I'm confused.
Quite a lot. Social capital. Culture. About a hundred other things.

A set of concepts popularized goes under the names of cycle of poverty, culture of poverty, and generational poverty. Simply being poor seems less predictive of outcomes than multiple generation being poor. If your parents, your grandparents, and your great grandparents were poor, it's very difficult to break out.

In this case, "culture" isn't a euphemism for laziness or something crass like that; for example, there's a certain body of knowledge that goes with knowing how to move into the middle class. If no one in your family has that, it's very, very hard. That goes for everything from knowing what's required to apply for college, to knowing how much you're expected to learn when, to having the background to know how to support your kids' schooling.

Intervention programs which provide that background are effective. Even something as simple as letting parents know to read to little kids, how to make sure kids do homework, what supports are available, etc. Beyond that, having a guidance counselor who can let you know what schools you're likely to get into, what you need to apply, and what is and isn't appropriate to have in an admissions essay. These things aren't rocket science, but if neither you nor anyone around you has done them, they're very, very hard.

Exactly. Then the current system that has vast racial imbalance, is unfair. Because those things brand a child as 'not smart'. So it needs reworking

And to say "Well, my kid is winning now so don't touch the system" is a weak argument.