Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rmc 5422 days ago
I see they have a Linux version. Is it Open Source?
2 comments
iam 5422 days ago
The biggest problem I have with centralized servers in the first place is that I don't trust my data with them. If it was decentralized and open source, that's an app I could see myself using.

Closed source = no good for privacy.

link
nroach 5421 days ago
I think that AeroFS only uses central servers to identify the IP addresses of participating hosts and negotiate a connection. AFAIK, the actual data flows directly peer to peer. So, even a malicious employee or government snoop would only know the IP of swarm participants. Presumably you'd still need to intercept and crack any encryption between nodes.
link
iam 5421 days ago
That's not the problem, the app being closed source and being able to do whatever it wants with my data is the problem.
link
rmc 5421 days ago
If the software is open source, it makes it much harder for a malicious company/employee to install a back door into the software.

It's not just the servers I have to trust, but the software. AeroFS gets rid of the servers, butt still need to trust the software.

link
drdaeman 5422 days ago
Probably not. At least it couldn't be a "private beta" then.
link
rmc 5422 days ago
I suppose.... but I'd be interested to hear their plans for when it's not a private beta. I would also be interested if the source code is visible to users (which is not the same thing as open source) . This transparency helps users know how safe their data is.
link