Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by thehappypm 1716 days ago
What’s a counter example?
1 comments

My router and my desktop is one of several billion counterexamples.
Your route and desktop are not an example of an internet connection. That's an intranet connection. I think that's what they mean -- for two devices to be connected on the internet there's always (at least) routers in between.
I can infer what they mean, it doesn't make it a correct statement. Maybe I'm being pedantic, but routers are devices too, and I have computers with multiple NICs that act as routers as well as servers. Intranet vs internet is an arbitrary distinction. If a "device" has an IP address that's reachable from "the internet" then it's on the internet, regardless.
The article's point is that to get information from Device A to Device B across the internet is never a straight link from Device A to Device B, there are always middlemen whose purpose it is just to forward the data along. There's always something between the end nodes.
Yes, and that's simply and demonstrably false. There are not always middlemen, as I have already explained.
Sigh