Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by SuoDuanDao 1724 days ago
Hm. I find this very analogous to the MRNA vaccine debate: how high an error rate of a new technology do we accept, and to what degree does that choice have to be made at a community rather than an individual level?

I'd feel best if that decision was made at the smallest community level possible, so ideally county by county rather than federally. That lightens the burden of politicians making the wrong choice or being a citizen who disagrees with the right choice.

1 comments

You get far more localized really shitty situations if you devolve to that level. Sometimes central decision making is good.

Having to switch the mode of operation of your car depending on what side of various county lines you are on seems like an obvious regulatory failure.

The error rate would certainly go up at first due to the additional complexity, but the cost of each error goes down. Besides, I have to switch the speed at which I'm driving far more granularly than at county lines, and no one's worried about a car's ability to handle that.

I don't disagree that sometimes central decision making is good, but in a complicated situation where any decision will have some negative consequences depending on the specific context seems like a textbook case of not being one of them.