[toyg]

That's effectively what Council Tax was originally meant to be, but after a while nobody could be bothered with the survey activity. They even closed the door to piecemeal re-classification, after enough people started challenging the band their property sat in, by passing legislation that basically states the band is fixed as it is until Parliament says otherwise (i.e. likely forever).

[Mvandenbergh]

Council tax was never meant to be anything like property tax and was structured specifically to act in a different way.

For example: councils don't actually set their council tax rates by band. They set one rate which is the Band D rate. The rates of the other bands are then set based on fixed %s from that rate and the highest English rate (H) is only 200% of the Band D rate.

The value of the lowest valued band H (based on the 1991 price levels) property relative to the highest band D is 3.6x. So right away we see that as a % of property value the typical household (D is the most common) in any given place pays more than the highest valued local properties. Of course it is also the case that band H is open-ended.

There is then the fact that these are set and collected exclusively locally. That means that some of the lowest council tax rates in the country are in some of the richest places. Westminster and Wandsworth have Band D council tax in the £800s, Blaenau Gwent is over £2000!

[toyg]

> Council tax was never meant to be anything like property tax

Well, it was meant to look like a property tax, while at the same time ensuring it would disproportionately affect the lower classes, for sure. It was a Conservative measure, after all (which Tony Blair was obviously "intensely relaxed about", since it directed money to local authorities Labour controlled, hence it was never repealed). As wikipedia reports: "the Valuation Tribunal Service [...] states that: "The tax is a mix of a property tax and a personal tax".

> They set one rate which is the Band D rate.

Yeah, and they can't even be arsed to figure out if a Band D property in 1991 is still a Band D today - the roof might have fallen off since then, but hey, who's got time to do periodic surveys? Local councils have better things to do, obviously.