Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ryandrake 1720 days ago
One thing the article doesn't seem to address is why these cuts are happening? What motivates a streaming company to go out of its way to re-shape the aspect ratio of a film? It is totally possible to re-digitize film without changing aspect ratio. Look at the re-done Star Trek TNG Blu-rays, they're amazing and with the original aspect ratio preserved. All widescreen TVs I know will play 4:3 content perfectly fine. Is there some technical reason that a 4:3 video can't be streamed?
2 comments

There is just no feedback from viewers to managers making decisions, and people actually doing work cropping don't have authority to override them.
People probably don’t like the black bars. Or at least the people in charge think so.