Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by anderspitman 1730 days ago
> 'rclone'[2][3] which allows you to move data from cloud to cloud without involving your own bandwidth

Maybe I'm reading this wrong, but the data does pass through the machine where rclone is running. rclone does support remote-to-remote transfers[0], but I believe only for remotes of the same type (ie S3 to S3).

[0]: https://rclone.org/docs/#server-side-copy

1 comments

Does this mean "remotes that speak the S3 protocol", or "remotes that are S3"? The former would require S3 supporting induced requests (so it POSTed the data somewhere), the latter would require a "copy" operation on S3. I don't know which one is supported.
Server side copy only works within the same service provider, not across service providers.
Right because, how would that work otherwise?

Unless those providers natively supported this functionality (and they're incentivized to not) you'd _need_ an intermediary.