Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Aeolun 1731 days ago
Doesn’t that rather defeat the point though? I can set up a wildcard for fastmail and use any account name I want to sign up to services without any intervention from 1password.

Edit: saw someone point out this only works for one user per domain.

3 comments

I've been a happy Fastmail customer for years prior to working on this feature. I've used a wildcard with my Fastmail account, created a new email address for each service I sign up with, and stored that email address in 1Password. All by hand. It's a tiny hassle, but one that I think is worth it.

The Masked Email integration makes that entire process automatic. It's even easier than before. It's enough to convince a few Fastmail-using friends to start doing it.

Yeah I also do this: I own my domain and I use a catch-all setup at my email provider so <anything>@jpreston.xyz goes to my inbox.

I suppose the advantage with a non-custom domain is you leak no info about yourself, the masked email is 'just another Fastmail email address'. But doing it for a custom domain feels like it defeats the point, isn't it just like catch-all at that point?

The value is in knowing who leaked your email address, and being able to take action based on that. If you use a unique address for every service then you can know for certain random Internet store got hacked, or sold their database. In either case, you kill the credit card you used (privacy.com) for that store before it gets used elsewhere, saving you additional time and money on having to deal with your banks.
It lets you migrate without having to update your email across every account.

It’s what I do with a custom domain (though only have a handful of custom aliases currently).

Having this integrated in a first class way is a nice surprise and a really great feature imo.

It’ll make it easy to see who leaked your email and kill the alias while also not locking you into to fastmail forever as a provider.