Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by _vhns 1728 days ago
I help manage 10+ local newspaper websites, and moderation is a constant issue for us as well.

We want to provide a place for the local community to have civil discussions, but many folks are misinformed and pridefully vocal about their ignorance. We see constant racism, personal attacks, and off-topic comments.

Our approach has been to turn comments off on some stories, and even whole publications. We have human moderation and machine moderation.

A local hospital requested that we consider turning comments off on covid articles, because the commenters are littering the conversation area with false information and political attacks.

I used to think that I would love to see a censorship resistant internet experience like TOR replace our centralized systems, but I don't know now. George Carlin said it best; people are dumb. The less misinformation folks are able to access, the better our society will be.

I think folks should be able to discuss topics freely with an audience, but they need to build that audience on their own. They can use email, messengers, host a forum, etc. Online public/general forums are notoriously ineffective and a huge waste of time, unless there is a barrier to entry and repercussions for misbehavior.

1 comments

Newspapers used to solve this problem by severe throttling. Anyone could write a letter to the editor; almost none of them were printed. "Default deny" may have helped the newspaper maintain a monopoly on "truth", but it also kept it from turning into a sewer of trolls, propagandists, and the (sometimes deliberately) misinformed.