Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bsder 1730 days ago
No.

We had better solutions, but the combination of "FREE!" and "network effects" meant that the GitHub virus won and the Git host came along for the ride.

Even Linus hates the way GitHub does things, but he can't do anything about it at this point except complain.
2 comments
candu 1730 days ago
This is not a compelling argument against GitHub (and, as others note, it doesn't really have anything to do with the article, nor does it really add anything to the discussion.)

Why does Linus hate "the way GitHub does things"? Are you referring to this [1] (which, I'll note, is ambivalent on the value of GitHub as a whole, and is only negative specifically on the matter of GitHub merges?) Or is there some other argument here that we're all supposed to be familiar with?

What are these "better solutions"? Where are they? Where can I find and use them? Are they, in fact, better thought-out and more usable than GitHub? How can I test your assertions here?

[1] https://lore.kernel.org/lkml/CAHk-=wjbtip559HcMG9VQLGPmkurh5...

link
bsder 1729 days ago
We had Monotone, Darcs and others. We still have Mercurial.

They all coexisted and were being developed. Even Github wasn't a big deal in the beginning and was just one of many providers who were all bootstrapped.

However, once GitHub hit the field with $100 million in VC cash it squashed further development cold--bootstrapping and quality doesn't matter much against someone burning VC cash against you.

Distributed source control is now in a path dependent local minimum and we are stuck with git because we are stuck with GitHub--better is no longer sufficient to break the logjam.

Until Microsoft turns the screws enough this will all remain status quo.

link
mkesper 1730 days ago
The discussion is about the 'git' command itself, not about Github.
link
bsder 1730 days ago
Except that we are talking about Github because something better than git can't exist because it also has to displace Github.
link
CRConrad 1728 days ago
What's to displace; who "needs" GitHub, and why? Just stop using it and use git (or whatever you want to use in stead).
link
rsfern 1729 days ago
Shouldn’t it be feasible to build an interoperable version control system so you can still collaborate on GitHub?
link