Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Biganon 1741 days ago
People always explain that. Unless they have no idea what they're talking about. It's an essential part of the paradox.
2 comments

The original problem formulation lacked it. Also this comic lacked it. Most people who describe the problem doesn't include the titbit. It is a very misunderstood point, you can even see it everywhere in this thread.
You're entirely right, and in your other comment as well. I just recognized this was about Monty Hall and didn't even bother reading the details. I also assumed other people would do the same: mentally invoke the entire paradox. It is indeed true that someone discovering the paradox with this comic wouldn't have nearly enough info to understand it, and would be correct to say it's wrong.
Second panel: "You pick one, then the host reveals that one of the other doors hides a goat. Should you switch?"
Right, the host revealed a goat this time. It didn't say the host always revealed a goat. The sentence is very clear on that point.
The "Math Goblins" comic does not explain it.